He's Trying To Fill In The Gaps On Google Street View — Starting With Zimbabwe

Sep 22, 2019
Originally published on September 23, 2019 12:58 pm

One of the first things people do when they use Google Street View is check out the place where they live.

So when Tawanda Kanhema moved to the United States in 2009, he looked up his hometown of Harare, Zimbabwe's capital city, on the map of panoramic images. A self-described tech enthusiast now some 10,000 miles away from home, he was eager to see a virtual tour of the city.

But there was nothing to see. Harare wasn't on Street View. The busy streets and shops, the schools he attended — none of it was there, and neither was the rest of Zimbabwe, a country in southern Africa with a population of more than 14 million. As Kanhema looked around more, many Western cities were on the platform, but only a handful of African countries were.

"When you look at Street View, you're looking at this mosaic of images that show how people live across the world, how people conduct commerce, how people get around," he says. "I found it quite jarring that a lot of the countries in the region were not on the map."

As services like Google Maps have increasingly become our primary map of the world, being left out of features like Street View can have consequences. Street View helps people with everyday tasks like checking out a new commute route, choosing a restaurant or deciding where to go on vacation. The platform also provides a trove of data used by Google to improve its mapping services, by academics for research and by local governments looking to make improvements to an area.

For Kanhema, the omission highlighted a digital divide between his hometown and major Western cities.

So he decided to try to get Zimbabwe on Street View. Kanhema, who works as a product manager in Silicon Valley and is a freelance photographer in his spare time, volunteered to carry Google's Street View gear to map what amounted to 2,000 miles of his home country. The Berkeley, Calif., resident has filled in the map of other areas in Africa and Canada as well.

Kanhema, in Namibia in early 2019, plans his route to document the country for Google Street View.
Alan Sanchez

"We should do more to make sure that those communities are represented," Kanhema says. "We should do more to showcase the businesses, the local businesses in those areas and also the tourist attractions."

"Is that a camera?"

Google says it has "largely mapped" only 87 of nearly 200 countries on the platform, which launched in 2007. Many other countries on the planet have at least some Street View coverage, Google says. But there are sizable gaps in regions like Africa, Antarctica and Central Asia, while areas such as the U.S. and Europe are mostly filled in. While users can see almost every street corner in places such as Paris or New York, they can't do the same for Algiers, Algeria, or Kabul, Afghanistan.

"We start in the large metropolitan areas where we know we have users, where it's easy for us to drive and we can execute quickly," says Stafford Marquardt, a product manager for Street View.

He says the team is working to expand the service's reach. To do that, Google often relies on volunteers who can either borrow the company's camera equipment or take photos using their own. Most images on Street View are collected by drivers, and most of these drivers are employed by third parties that work with Google. But when it comes to the places Google hasn't prioritized, people like Kanhema can fill in the gaps.

In 2018, Kanhema applied to borrow a 360-degree camera through Google's Street View camera loan program, and in the fall, he took a two-week trek through Zimbabwe with the equipment. There was a speedboat ride across the Zambezi River and a safari trip through a national park. Most of his time, though, was spent driving down the streets of Harare and the highways that connect Zimbabwe's major cities.

For Kanhema, returning home to do Street View meant translating the experience of Harare for users around the world who might never travel there. And everywhere he went, Google's camera — a tall, alien-like device — went with him.

"It's so conspicuous to have a 4-foot contraption attached to the roof of your car," Kanhema says. "People are walking up and asking questions about, 'Is that a camera? What are you recording? What are you filming? It is for Google Maps? Will my house be on the map? Will my face be on the map?' "

Many of the places Kanhema photographed were tourist attractions, such as the massive Victoria Falls, which he captured from 400 feet above, strapping the Street View camera to the dashboard of a helicopter.

He sees his work as a form of documentary photography. And he's hoping his images will draw tourists to the region and boost his home country's economy.

"Imagine being able to lend a ticket to get on a helicopter tour of one of the seven natural wonders of the world and being able to bring at least a million other people with you by creating these images that people can look at and feel as though they were there," he says.

Kanhema with Google Street View equipment in Swakopmund, on Namibia's coast.
Alan Sanchez

Kanhema has since uploaded those images to Street View, and Google has also added businesses to the map in the areas of Harare that he drove.

All this is a lot of work, but for Kanhema, it's a hobby. Google doesn't pay him or the other volunteers — whom the company calls "contributors" — for the content they upload. Kanhema, for example, spent around $5,000 of his own money to travel across Zimbabwe for the project.

"What motivates me is just being that constant nudge on these companies and this system to pay attention to those parts of the world," he says.

Marquardt says Google currently has no plans to compensate its volunteers, adding that it pays contributors "in a lot of other ways" by offering "a platform to host gigabytes and terabytes of imagery and publish it to the entire world, absolutely for free."

How people live across the world

Craig Dalton, an assistant professor of global studies and geography at Hofstra University, says Google's business model plays a big role in which places are added to Street View first.

"Google Maps is not a public service. Google Maps is a product from a company, and things are included and excluded based on the company's needs," Dalton says. "Sometimes that means that things are excluded that have a lot of merit but that don't fit the business plan. And sometimes that means that things are included even if that feels like a violation of our privacy."

The company has been criticized for violating privacy through the mapping project. In 2013, Google paid a $7 million fine to settle claims that it improperly collected data from unsecured wireless networks across the U.S. using its Street View cars.

Although the company's end goal is to make a global street map, Kanhema is unsure when places like his hometown would be visible on the platform without volunteered images.

"There's not always going to be a business case to tell the story of how people live across the world," he says.

For now, Kanhema has found other ways to receive compensation for his work. Most recently, in March, the Mushkegowuk Council, in northern Ontario, paid him to document the network of ice roads that connect indigenous communities in the area.

Often Street View contributors can also receive funding from tourism boards or travel agencies, but Kanhema says he wants to avoid that model. Those arrangements can mean restrictions on what he maps and when, like business owners who want to make sure their storefronts look busy or clean when the photographs are taken.

Next up, Kanhema says he might head to Greenland, or maybe Alaska or Mozambique — and you'll be able to see everything he has seen by clicking on Google Maps.

Correction: 9/22/19

A photo caption in an earlier version of this story incorrectly stated that Tawanda Kanhema was in Harare, Zimbabwe. He was in Victoria Falls.

Copyright 2020 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

MICHEL MARTIN, HOST:

If you've ever used Google Street View to plan a vacation or house-hunt, then you know that you can see almost every corner in the U.S. But Africa and other places are almost completely left off the map. NPR's Chloee Weiner has the story of someone who's trying to fill in the map, starting with Zimbabwe.

CHLOEE WEINER, BYLINE: Tawanda Kanhema is driving up Samora Machel Avenue, a crowded street in his hometown, Harare, the capital city of Zimbabwe.

TAWANDA KANHEMA: And to my left is the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe, which happens to be the tallest building in the city. And you can feel the energy of this commercial center and cultural center of about 2.6 million people that live here.

WEINER: If he sounds like a tour guide, he is, a tour guide for the whole world. He has a camera strapped on the roof of his car.

KANHEMA: The camera kind of looks like an alien. It's got six eyes and what looks like a mouth.

WEINER: It's an odd sight, Kanhema says. So he gets a lot of questions from people as he passes.

KANHEMA: Is that a camera? What are you recording? What are you filming?

WEINER: It's a 360-degree camera that Kanhema is using to put images of his hometown on the map - Google Street View map, that is. Kanhema spend a few thousand dollars of his own money to do it because Google didn't pay.

STAFFORD MARQUARDT: We do pay them back in a lot of other ways.

WEINER: That Stafford Marquardt, a product manager for Street View. He says Google's ultimate goal is to make a Street View map of the whole world. To do that, Google relies on volunteers to capture places the company hasn't prioritized.

MARQUARDT: Google pays Street View car drivers through our official Google Street View fleet. When contributors decide to map the areas that are important to them, we offer a free platform to host gigabytes and terabytes of imagery and publish it to the entire world absolutely for free.

KANHEMA: There's not always going to be a business case to tell the story of how people live across the world.

WEINER: That's Kanhema again. He sees these gaps on Street View as a digital divide.

KANHEMA: I found it quite jarring that a lot of the countries in the region were not on the map.

WEINER: When Kanhema's not working as a product manager in Silicon Valley, he's a freelance photographer. He traverses Zimbabwe by foot, by car, by boat, even on a helicopter ride over Victoria Falls.

KANHEMA: Imagine being able to lend a ticket to get on a helicopter tour of one of the seven natural wonders of the world and being able to bring at least a million other people with you.

WEINER: He sees his work as a form of documentary photography, and he's hoping these images will bring in potential tourists and boost Zimbabwe's economy.

KANHEMA: So there's a sense of responsibility that comes with that. I'm not just here to document a place. I'm here to document the place and then go on to the next level to think - what can we do to improve the way people live in this place?

MARQUARDT: We've added businesses to every block of Harare that Tawanda drove, and that's important in bringing good maps and good directions and good date night-finding to all the people in Zimbabwe.

WEINER: That's Google's Stafford Marquardt again. Recently, Kanhema took Google's camera to northern Ontario. A local government hired him to capture the ice roads that connect native communities there before they're forever altered by climate change.

KANHEMA: You feel this very strong sense of solitude. We've probably only met two cars. There's really not much to see besides the vast endless expanse of ice. It's the coldest place I've been to.

WEINER: So far, Kanhema's mission has added 700,000 new images to Street View. Next stop, he might head to Greenland or maybe Alaska or Mozambique. And you can see everything he's seen by clicking on Google Maps.

Chloee Weiner, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.