For Some, Zoom Bar And Bat Mitzvahs Highlight 'Most Meaningful And Memorable Moments'

May 16, 2020
Originally published on May 16, 2020 8:34 am

As Gabe Silverman chants his Torah portion, he's intensely focused on every word. It's the culmination of months of study and the high point of his Bar Mitzvah service. The same is true for almost every 12- or 13-year-old celebrating a bar or bat mitzvah.

"For the Torah service, I was very nervous about, like, losing my place," Gabe said. "It's so big and all the letters look the same, basically."

The Torah is rolled open on a table in his family's living room and positioned in front of a computer camera. Gabe is sheltering at home with his parents and younger brother and this is the first Zoom mitzvah for Temple Shir Tikva, a congregation located 20 miles west of Boston.

May and June are popular months for bar and bat mitzvahs and many congregations schedule the Jewish coming-of-age ritual two to three years in advance. It takes time to learn Torah portions and prayers and to book venues and caterers for the celebration afterwards.

That makes postponing tough.

Now, during the coronavirus pandemic, congregations are reimagining the ceremony and bringing it online.

For family and friends watching Gabe's Zoom bar mitzvah, Gabe and the Torah occupy a central square flanked by Shir Tikva's rabbis and cantor.

Rabbi Danny Burkeman calls upon a few family members. They temporarily appear on screen for aliyot -- blessings over the Torah reading. Gabe's grandmother Helaine Silverman is honored with the first of the aliyot. Before Helaine begins, Burkeman reminds her to switch on her camera and unmute.

Burkeman leads the service remotely from his synagogue's main sanctuary. He's doing double duty, making sure the ceremony follows tradition and monitoring all the technology involved.

"Our aim was to create for them as much as possible a digital bar mitzvah experience," Burkeman said. "And we use the word digital because it wasn't virtual. There was nothing virtual about it. It was real."

Rabbi Danny Burkeman delivers the Torah two days before the bar mitzvah.
Erica Silverman

The Silvermans thought about postponing until the end of the year, but two weeks before the big day, they decided to go forward on Zoom on the original date. At that point, the most pressing question became: What elements of the bar mitzvah mattered most?

Gabe wanted to read from an actual Torah, not the sheets of paper he used for practice. Two days before his bar mitzvah, Burkeman made a special delivery.

"Rabbi Danny just came to our driveway with the Torah seatbelted in the front seat," Gabe recalled. "It was wrapped up, seatbelted, and then he handed it off to my dad."

At his bar mitzvah, as soon as Gabe finishes reading from that Torah, he looks at his parents, smiles and noticeably exhales. For him, the toughest part is over.

Soon the entire service concludes. Then, Burkeman exhales.

"I felt really good that we'd been able to give him an experience," Burkeman said. "And you could see in his face and in the face of his family that this was meaningful for them."

Gabe wanted to read from an actual Torah, not the sheets of paper he used for practice.
The Silvermans

After the ceremony, family and friends turn on their cameras and unmute. They wave and hold up congratulatory signs and shout "Mazel Tov!"

Reflecting on the bar mitzvah, Gabe's mom Erica is happy with the whole online event, but she knows it's not for everyone.

"I'm very compassionate for people who are making the other decision to postpone and do it in person," she said. "But for us, in that moment, it was the right decision. It was more special because of the circumstances."

As she talks, Erica sits next to Gabe and her husband Scott. The Torah is still there, a couple feet away on the dining room table.

She glances over at the scroll and adds, "I feel very complete by what we experienced."

Erica and Scott wonder if they'll need to celebrate with a big bar mitzvah party when family and friends can gather again. And Gabe?

"I hope that we can have a party," he said. "But I can do without."

The pandemic has made the service — the actual religious ritual — the place where the most meaningful and memorable moments happen.

Copyright 2020 WBUR. To see more, visit WBUR.

SCOTT SIMON, HOST:

Bar and bat mitzvahs are getting reimagined during the pandemic. Some congregations are holding these coming-of-age ceremonies online, as Shira Springer of member station WBUR in Boston reports.

SHIRA SPRINGER, BYLINE: Earlier this month, Temple Shir Tikva, just outside Boston, held its first Zoom mitzvah.

GABE SILVERMAN: (Speaking Hebrew).

SPRINGER: That's Gabe Silverman reading from the Torah. It's rolled open on a table in his family's living room.

G SILVERMAN: (Speaking Hebrew).

SPRINGER: The Torah service is the high point of any bar or bat mitzvah. It's the culmination of months, sometimes years of studying.

G SILVERMAN: For the Torah service, I was very nervous about, like, losing my place because it's so big and that all the letters look the same, basically.

SPRINGER: Gabe's sheltering at home with his parents and younger brother. For family and friends watching on Zoom, Gabe and the Torah occupy a central square flanked by Shir Tikva's rabbis and cantor. Rabbi Danny Burkeman calls upon a few family members. They temporarily appear on screen for aliyot - blessings over the Torah reading.

DANNY BURKEMAN: (Speaking Hebrew). And we call out Helaine Silverman, who will hopefully switch on her camera and will unmute.

HELAINE SILVERMAN: (Speaking Hebrew).

BURKEMAN: (Speaking Hebrew).

SPRINGER: Burkeman leads the service remotely from his synagogue's main sanctuary, making sure the ceremony follows tradition and monitoring all the technology involved.

BURKEMAN: And so our aim was to create for them as much as possible a digital bar mitzvah experience. And we use the word digital because it wasn't virtual. There was nothing virtual about it. It was real.

SPRINGER: Many congregations schedule bar or bat mitzvahs two to three years in advance. That makes postponing tough. Two weeks before the big day, the Silvermans decided to go forward with a Zoom bar mitzvah. Gabe explains two days before the service...

G SILVERMAN: Rabbi Danny just came to our drive with a Torah seat belted in the front seat.

(LAUGHTER)

SCOTT SILVERMAN: Wrapped up.

G SILVERMAN: Yeah, wrapped up, seat belted. And then he handed it off to my dad.

SPRINGER: At his bar mitzvah, as soon as Gabe finishes reading from that Torah, he looks at his parents, smiles, and noticeably exhales. For him, the toughest part is over. Soon the entire service concludes. Then Burkeman exhales.

BURKEMAN: And I felt really good that we'd been able to give him an experience. And you could see in his face and in the face of his family that this was meaningful for them.

SPRINGER: After the ceremony, family and friends turn on their cameras and unmute.

UNIDENTIFIED PERSON: Mazel tov!

ERICA SILVERMAN: Thank you guys so much.

UNIDENTIFIED PERSON: Mazel tov!

SPRINGER: Gabe's mom, Erica, is happy with the whole online event, but she knows it's not for everyone.

E SILVERMAN: I'm very compassionate for people who are making the other decision to postpone and do it in person. But for us, in that moment, it was, like, the right decision. And I don't want to take away from people who are making this decision, but it was more special because of the circumstances.

SPRINGER: Erica's sitting next to Gabe and her husband, Scott. The Torah is still there, a couple feet away on the dining room table.

E SILVERMAN: And I feel very complete by what we experienced.

SPRINGER: Erica and Scott wonder if they'll need to celebrate with a big bar mitzvah party when family and friends can gather again. And Gabe?

G SILVERMAN: I hope that we can have a party, but I can do without.

E SILVERMAN: (Speaking Hebrew).

SPRINGER: The pandemic has made the service - the actual religious ritual - the place where the most memorable and meaningful moments happen. For NPR News, I'm Shira Springer in Boston. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.