Some Faith Leaders Defiant, Others Transparent Over COVID-19 Outbreaks

Nov 19, 2020
Originally published on November 19, 2020 3:34 pm

The day after the Maine Center for Disease Control and Prevention announced an outbreak at Calvary Baptist Church in Sanford, Pastor Todd Bell stood at his pulpit for in-person service.

The state was in the middle of tracing a "super-spreader wedding event" and investigating whether Calvary Baptist was linked. After members of the church's choir stood shoulder to shoulder on stage and sang, unmasked, Bell turned his attention to the outbreak. He railed against public health officials for intervening in the church's affairs.

"You're looking at a liberty lover!" Bell told the congregation. "I — love — liberty. And I want the people of God to enjoy liberty!"

Bell said wearing masks was like trying to keep out a mosquito with a chain link fence. His response drew fierce criticism and national media attention. Ultimately, nine cases were identified at Calvary Baptist Church. Since then, at least a half dozen other congregations in Maine have had outbreaks. Many faith leaders have shied away from attention. But Pastor Matt Burden of the Second Baptist Church in Calais, Maine, has taken a more public health-minded approach. When some members of his congregation tested positive for COVID-19, he posted a Facebook video to spread the word.

"It's been kind of a crazy week," he says in the video, sitting on a couch in his home with his young daughter by his side. "We certainly would want to recommend anyone from our church family who is experiencing any kind of symptoms, or anything like that, please isolate, get yourself tested."

This may seem like a natural response, but Burden says there's a strong temptation to keep this kind of situation under wraps.

"It would have been really a lot easier road for me, if I hadn't opened my mouth so much," he says, now.

That's because opening up put the Second Baptist Church under a magnifying glass. And urging members of the congregation to get tested meant that more COVID-19 cases would likely be discovered and associated with the church. So far, there have been more than two dozen cases. It's the second largest church outbreak in Maine. Burden says the situation has been especially disheartening because he had implemented safety measures. The church offered two services to limit crowd size and roped off pews for social distancing. Masks were recommended but not required during services.

"To be honest, it was really hard," Burden says. Calais is a rural city of 3,000 residents perched on the border of Canada. "We were in an area that was not hard hit by the coronavirus for most of the summer, the early fall. And we were among the most cautious institutions in town. Even amongst my own congregation, you know, people have been very supportive, they're willing to play by the rules. But there is a feeling amongst some people that, 'Why are we doing all this stuff?'"

The director of the Maine CDC, Dr. Nirav Shah, says when it comes to the coronavirus, churches are of special concern.

"Some of the things that can generate COVID-19 are literally the reasons you go to church for — fellowship, close camaraderie, singing," he says.

When outbreaks do erupt in houses of worship, Shah says it requires a more deft response compared to other settings.

"I think it's safe to say that for the past, you know, 2,000 to 3,000 years, those who attend different houses of worship have felt besieged, no matter what your faith," he says.

Building trust, Shah says, is the biggest challenge. But he doesn't fault people for being reticent about sharing.

"It's my job to build that trust, to convince them that sharing who they were at service with, will be used for good," he says.

Pastor Burden's church decided being transparent was in the best interests of the community, but he understands why some churches are more reluctant. There's a sense, he says, that churches are singled out for blame in ways that other institutions or businesses aren't.

"So I'm very sympathetic to the way that a lot of other churches are trying to wrestle with this. It's not an easy thing," the pastor says.

Burden gives frequent updates on his congregation's COVID-19 situation in Facebook posts, and he says his transparency has yielded some positive attention. Several pastors have called to offer support. Others have also asked how they can avoid an outbreak.

"It's an interesting call to take from someone who wants to know how not to end up like you," he says. "But I understand where they're coming from, right?"

Because, Burden says, no congregation wants to end up in the headlines for a COVID-19 outbreak.

Copyright 2020 Maine Public. To see more, visit Maine Public.

ARI SHAPIRO, HOST:

When an outbreak of COVID-19 happens at a church, it can attract scrutiny. As Maine Public Radio's Patty Wight reports, some church leaders respond defiantly while others take a more public health-minded approach.

PATTY WIGHT, BYLINE: The first known COVID-19 outbreak at a church in Maine happened at the Calvary Baptist Church in the city of Sanford. At the time, the state CDC was tracing a superspreader wedding event and investigating whether the church was linked. The day after the state announced the outbreak, Pastor Todd Bell stood at his pulpit for in-person service.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

TODD BELL: You're looking at a liberty lover.

WIGHT: He railed against public health officials for intervening in the church's affairs.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

BELL: I love liberty, and I want the people of God to enjoy liberty.

WIGHT: Bell told his congregation that wearing masks was like trying to keep out a mosquito with a chain-link fence. His response drew fierce criticism. Ultimately, nine cases were identified at Calvary Baptist Church. Since then, at least a half-dozen other congregations in Maine have had outbreaks. But not all have responded with defiance.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

MATT BURDEN: It's been kind of a crazy week.

WIGHT: That's Pastor Matt Burden of the Second Baptist Church in the city of Calais speaking in a Facebook video.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

BURDEN: We have had a few cases of confirmed positive coronavirus pop up among some of our church people.

WIGHT: In his Facebook video, Burden asks for prayers for people who tested positive and urges those with symptoms to isolate and get tested. This may seem like a natural response, but Burden says the temptation to keep the situation under wraps is strong.

BURDEN: It would have been a really - a lot easier road for me if I hadn't opened my mouth so much.

WIGHT: Opening up put the Second Baptist Church under a magnifying glass, and urging members of the congregation to get tested meant that more COVID-19 cases would likely be discovered and associated with the church. So far, there have been more than two dozen cases. It's the second-largest church outbreak in Maine. Houses of worship account for just a fraction of the state's COVID-19 cases, but Maine CDC Director Dr. Nirav Shah says they are of special concern.

NIRAV SHAH: Some of the things that can generate COVID-19 are literally the reasons you go to church for - fellowship, close camaraderie, singing.

WIGHT: When outbreaks do erupt in houses of worship, Shah says it requires a more deft response compared to other settings.

SHAH: I think it's safe to say that for the past, you know, 2- to 3,000 years, those who attend different houses of worship have felt besieged, no matter what your faith.

WIGHT: Building trust, Shah says, is the biggest challenge. Pastor Matt Burden says his church decided to be transparent for the health of the community, but he understands why some churches are more reluctant.

BURDEN: A sense that communities are singling them out for blame in a way that other institutions aren't. So I'm very sympathetic to the way that a lot of other churches are trying to wrestle with this. And it's not an easy thing.

WIGHT: Burden gives frequent updates on his congregation's COVID-19 situation in Facebook posts, and he says his transparency has yielded some positive attention. Several pastors have called to offer support. Others have also asked how they can avoid an outbreak.

BURDEN: It's an interesting call to take from someone who wants to know how not to end up like you. But I understand where they're coming from, right?

WIGHT: Because, he says, no congregation wants to end up in the headlines for a COVID-19 outbreak.

For NPR News, I'm Patty Wight in Lewiston, Maine. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.