NPR Ed published the first-ever database of the most popular high school plays and musicals in the U.S. in July 2015. Today, the 2020 numbers are out, so we've updated our original story.
Mary Poppins is out and Matilda is in, according to the new high school theater rankings from the Educational Theatre Association. The top spot for high school musicals went to The Addams Family, a show that's been hanging around the top 10 list for the last decade. Mamma Mia! was the second most-popular, making an appearance on the list for the second year (the rights for schools recently became available). Cinderella rounded out the Top 10 list — a new addition this year.
For full-length plays, Clue finally beat out Almost, Maine (the most popular production for high schools this decade) for the No. 1 spot. The rankings come out as schools across the country are being challenged to adapt their theater and concert performances to online platforms because of the coronavirus.
For Vernon Hills High School in Illinois, Clue was a great choice because of its creativity and humor, says Stephanie Freichels, the school's theater director. "It combines mystery with some really great physical comedy," she says. "There are secret passageways and over-the-top characters."
The school wasn't able to perform the show as planned last spring due to the coronavirus, so over Zoom, the cast and crew created a radio drama. They sold tickets and streamed the audio for "one night only!" in May.
This year, 85 percent of nearly 3,300 schools surveyed by the EdTA said they had canceled performances, and many educators say they'll feel the financial impact from that this year.
Money made from ticket sales in the spring often funds the fall shows. For nearly half of the schools surveyed, financial losses from cancelled shows mean cutbacks for next year's theater and arts-related activities. At Vernon Hills High, where they're planning to hold classes remotely in the fall, staff are still working on a plan for theater. Perhaps another radio play is in their future!
The back story
Even though I myself did not bask in the glow of the high school stage, I do have fond memories of working behind the scenes, as stage crew. Dressed in black, I rushed the bed onstage for Tevye's dream sequence in Fiddler on the Roof.
I've also spoken with many people who weren't involved in theater at all but can still — for some reason — remember the shows their schools performed.
There's just something about the high school stage.
All of this got me wondering: What are the most popular high school plays and musicals?
As it turns out, the answer is in Dramatics — the monthly magazine for theater students and teachers. It's been publishing an annual ranking of the most popular high school plays and musicals since 1938.
No one had ever compiled the data. The information wasn't even digitized. So in the winter of 2014, Don Corathers, the magazine's editor, began digging through the archives for hard copies of each original issue — nearly 100 pages in all.
During the process, he wrote to explain a delay: "What's taking so long, other than the distraction of publishing a magazine, is that we have to locate the articles in bound copies in order to scan them."
Eventually, he found them all, made copies — a huge stack — and mailed them to the NPR Ed team here in Washington, D.C. And last year, NPR Ed compiled the data. Today, we've updated the collection.
Over the past 78 years, the most popular plays have consistently been Our Town and You Can't Take It with You, according to our analysis.
Why, you ask?
"Most high school teachers need a big cast, lots of female roles, and something that won't scare your grandma," says Corathers, who has been with Dramatics since 1979.
For both plays: check, check and check.
You Can't Take It with You has been performed so often that it led to this cheeky 2008 photo caption: "You Can't Take It with You — but evidently you can perform it forever."
Indeed. Even into the 1980s it was the most-produced high school play in America, topping the list every year that decade but one, 1982, when it fell just short of Our Town.
Oldies but goodies
One thing is obvious: These plays are old.
"The consciousness of school theater seems to be stuck in about 1954" — so says a 1992 issue of Dramatics. And in 2007: "Our straight plays are getting older. A lot older."
"In the '60s the language and subject matter changed," explains Corathers. "It was also excruciatingly expensive to put on a play, so new plays had small casts. People were just not writing plays that could be produced in high schools."
In 1976 — noticing that schools were eschewing new for old — the magazine's editors wrote an op-ed. They urged schools to produce more contemporary works.
"Only four plays are fresh to the list this year," editor Thomas Barker bemoaned. "Four of sixty-eight."
Barker's argument: Theater should reflect society, and society had changed.
A year later — with little movement in the rankings — the editors backed down:
"No more going out on limbs, no more coaxing, no more labored analysis," they wrote. "We will let the charts speak for themselves."
And Corathers believes that, even today, those old staples of the stage are still relevant. Good theater is good theater, he says, no matter when it was written.
Looking at the nearly 80 years of data, another trend stands out: More often than not, popular plays stayed popular over time.
Corathers offers this explanation: School theater directors and educators use the magazine's survey to find ideas for next year. The rankings make it easy for a theater director to sell the school's principal on a safe slate.
In short, says Corathers: "The list becomes self-perpetuating."
Oh, the musicals!
Musicals didn't really make waves in rankings until 1960. But Bye Bye Birdie and Oklahoma! have been the most popular titles ever since.
In recent years, musical tastes appear to have shifted, with more contemporary titles moving up the list.
Disney Theatrical plays a substantial role. "Live theater is adapting animated films," says Corathers, pointing to Beauty and the Beast. "They are instantly family-friendly. They are familiar stories with great songs and lovely music."
In 2009, Dramatics noted that Memorial High School in Houston was on trend as it performed Disney's Beauty and the Beast — the top-ranked musical of the current decade.
But don't retire the standards just yet. During the 1963-64 school year, the magazine highlighted a performance by Preston High School in Preston, Idaho, of Bye Bye Birdie — the fourth most popular musical of the 1960s. It then cracked the top five in the '70s, '80s, '90s and 2000s.
The rights to perform
One last tidbit. The popularity of many productions (especially musicals) seems to depend almost entirely on licensing. High schools can't produce a show until it has run its course on Broadway and in regional theaters.
In 1975, the amateur performance rights for Godspell became available, and it's rumored that the licensing agency's telephone switchboards were jammed for days after. That year, Godspell was the top high school musical.
Same's true for Les Miserables. The school version was released in 2002. And by 2003, it had cracked the top of the list.
For many of these years, the Dramatics data set for high school productions served as more of an index than a comprehensive ranking. Our own Bob Mondello (movie critic, yes, but also a theater aficionado) reminds us that "the Educational Theater Association is only polling its member schools in the lists it prints in Dramatics. The organization had 500 members in 1938; it has close to 5,000 today."
Corathers estimates about 12,000 high schools in the U.S. have drama programs.
For 2017, the survey's reach widened, with more than 3,000 schools responding. For the first time, the survey asked how many people came to see them. The answer? Nearly 50 million.
How We Did This
In a spreadsheet, we compiled separate lists of the plays and musicals listed in Dramatics' annual survey. Because of inconsistencies in the lists over time (some years included the number of schools while others listed only a rank), we scored shows according to their rank in a given year: 15 points to the No. 1 show, 14 points to the second, and so on. Any show that ranked below 14 was awarded 1 point. For more information on this project, email email@example.com.
RACHEL MARTIN, HOST:
There is nothing quite like a high school musical. It's my kind of entertainment, frankly, but little did I know there are people out in the world who actually keep track of the most popular high school plays and musicals. Here's a couple of the headlines out of this list - joining the top 10 - "Annie;" falling off the list - "Grease," which is crazy to me. It first showed up on these rankings in 1981. This is all according to Dramatics magazine. They've been collecting the top plays and musicals since 1938. Elissa Nadworny from the NPR Ed team reports.
ELISSA NADWORNY, BYLINE: There's just something about the high school stage. For me, it was "Fiddler On The Roof."
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSICAL, "FIDDLER ON THE ROOF")
UNIDENTIFIED ACTORS: (As characters, singing) For such a match, I prayed. Mazel tov, mazel tov.
NADWORNY: I was stage crew, dressed in black, and I rushed the bed onstage for Tevye's dream sequence. In the early 2000s, "Fiddler" was a big hit with high schools. So what's popular now? On the musical side, "Beauty And The Beast" took the top spot.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSICAL, "BEAUTY AND THE BEAST")
UNIDENTIFIED ACTORS: (As characters, singing) Bon jour, bon jour, bon jour, bon jour, bon jour.
NADWORNY: Those are students from Gonzaga College High School in Washington, D.C. This spring, they joined schools all across the country, from Puyallup, Wash., to Fort Dodge, Iowa, to Billings, Mont., performing the show. Coul Hill is the theater teacher behind Skyview High School's production in Billings.
COUL HILL: I like special effects, and I like having people fly and swing and fall and all of that.
NADWORNY: But, he says, theater in Montana can be a hard sell, so he picked a show he knew kids would love.
HILL: If they haven't already watched the Disney version of it a hundred times, they don't care, right? So it's got to be stuff that they're already familiar with.
NADWORNY: "Beauty And The Beast" fit that bill, and it was a huge success. They're not alone with that reasoning. Belle and her friends have been hanging around the top-10 list for the last two decades. Shifting from musicals to plays, "Almost, Maine," a collection of two-person scenes by John Cariani, was No. 1, and it has been for seven of the last nine years.
(SOUNDBITE OF PLAY, "ALMOST, MAINE")
UNIDENTIFIED ACTOR #1: (As Marvalyn) What is it like...
UNIDENTIFIED ACTOR #2: (As Steve) What?
UNIDENTIFIED ACTOR #1: (As Marvalyn) To not feel pain?
UNIDENTIFIED ACTOR #2: (As Steve) I don't know. I don't really know what it's like to hurt.
NADWORNY: Those are students from Carl Junction High School in Missouri. Many of the plays and musicals are classics. And there's "Our Town." The play ranked No. 5 this past school year. It's been one of the top plays every decade since the 1940s. One factor here - it's pretty cheap to put on.
GREGORY BOSSLER: You can do it with at least a ladder, and I think that's the minimum you need.
NADWORNY: That's Gregory Bossler, editor in chief of Dramatics magazine. He oversees the theater rankings and was a high school actor back in the day.
BOSSLER: And my senior year, I was even the lead in the spring musical. I was Captain von Trapp in "The Sound Of Music."
NADWORNY: Bossler says shows with a lot of roles and big ensembles like "Our Town" work well. "Beauty And The Beast" has lots of villagers, plus Mrs. Potts, Lumiere, Gaston and Little Chip.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSICAL, "BEAUTY AND THE BEAST")
UNIDENTIFIED ACTORS: (As characters, singing) Be our guest, be our guest.
NADWORNY: About 4,000 schools filled out this annual survey from Dramatics magazine. The survey asked how many people came to see the shows, and with some math, they estimate about 46 million people are seeing theater at high schools every year. That's about four times the number of folks that see a show on Broadway. One of the appeals of student theater, Bossler says, is seeing teens grapple with emotions and relevant issues. Take "The Little Mermaid."
BOSSLER: She wants to be part of your world. It's someone dealing with feeling like an outsider, and I don't know what high schooler has never felt that emotion.
NADWORNY: As the curtain falls, let's let Cody Putz at Half Moon Bay High School in California close us out.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSICAL, "THE LITTLE MERMAID")
CODY PUTZ: (As Ariel, singing) I want to be where the people are.
NADWORNY: Elissa Nadworny, NPR News.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSICAL, "THE LITTLE MERMAID")
PUTZ: (As Ariel, singing) ...Want to see them dancing. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.