In The Fight For Money For The Opioid Crisis, Will The Youngest Victims Be Left Out?

Nov 22, 2019
Originally published on November 22, 2019 5:27 pm

Babies born to mothers who used opioids during pregnancy represent one of the most distressing legacies of an opioid epidemic that has claimed almost 400,000 lives and ravaged communities.

In fact, many of the ongoing lawsuits filed against drug companies make reference to these babies, fighting through withdrawal in hospital nurseries.

The cluster of symptoms they experience, which include tremors, seizures and respiratory distress, is known as neonatal abstinence syndrome. Until recently, doctors rarely looked for the condition. Then case numbers quadrupled over a decade. Hospital care for newborns with NAS has cost Medicaid billions of dollars.

Studies indicate more than 30,000 babies with the condition are born every year in the U.S. — about one every 15 minutes. Although their plight is mentioned in opioid-related litigation, there are growing concerns that those same children will be left out of financial settlements being negotiated right now.

Robbie Nicholson now works as a mentor with a company called 180 Health Partners that helps women with addiction go through pregnancy. Her own newborn went through drug withdrawals, related to the medications she took to control her opioid cravings. She says most women she works with need a stable place to live and reliable transportation.
Blake Farmer

Robbie Nicholson, a mother in Eagleville, Tenn., tried to comfort her second child while the baby slowly underwent withdrawal from drugs Nicholson had taken during pregnancy.

"The whole experience is just traumatizing, really," Nicholson says.

Nicholson's ordeal actually began right after her first pregnancy. To help with postpartum recovery, her doctor prescribed her a pile of Percocets. That was the norm.

"Back then, it was like I was on them for a full month. And then he was like, 'OK, you're done.' And I was like, 'Oh my God, I've got a newborn, first-time mom, no energy, no sleep, like that was getting me through,' " she says. "It just built and built and built off that."

After developing a full-blown addiction to painkillers, Nicholson eventually found her way into recovery. In accordance with evidence-based guidelines, she took buprenorphine, a medication that helps keep her opioid cravings at bay. And then came another pregnancy.

But buprenorphine — as well as methadone, another drug used in medication-assisted addiction treatment — is a special kind of opioid. Its use during pregnancy can still result in withdrawal symptoms for the newborn, although increasingly physicians have decided that the benefits of keeping a mother on the medication, to help her stay sober and stable during pregnancy, outweigh the risk of her giving birth to a baby with neonatal abstinence syndrome.

Treatment protocols for NAS vary from hospital to hospital, but over time doctors and neonatal nurses have become better at diagnosing the condition and weaning newborns safely. Sometimes the mom and her baby can even stay together if the infant doesn't have to be sent to the neonatal intensive care unit.

But not much is known about the long-term effects of NAS, and parents and medical professionals both worry about the future of children exposed in utero to opioids.

"I wanted her to be perfect, and she is absolutely perfect," Nicholson says. "But in the back of my mind, it's always going to be there."

There are thousands of children like Nicholson's daughter entering the education system. Dr. Stephen Patrick, a neonatologist in Nashville, says schools and early childhood programs are on the front lines now.

"You hear teachers talking about infants with a development delay," he says. "I just got an email this morning from somebody."

Studies haven't proven a direct link between in utero exposure to opioids and behavior problems in kids. And it's challenging to untangle which problems might stem from the lingering effects of maternal drug use, as opposed to the impacts of growing up with a mother who struggles with addiction and perhaps unemployment and housing instability as well. But Patrick, who leads the Center for Child Health Policy at Vanderbilt University, says that is what his and others' ongoing research wants to find out.

As states, cities, counties and even hospitals go after drug companies in court, Patrick fears these children will be left out. He points to public discussion of pending settlements and the settlement deals struck between pharmaceutical companies and the state of Oklahoma, which make little or no mention of children.

Settlement funds could be used to monitor the health of children who had NAS, to pay for treatment of any developmental problems, and to help schools serving those children, Patrick explains.

"We need to be in the mix right now, in schools, understanding how we can support teachers, how we can support students as they try to learn, even as we work out was there cause and effect of opioid use and developmental delays or issues in school," he says.

New mothers in recovery for opioid addiction meet with a support group in Oak Ridge, Tenn. Most had newborns who endured drug withdrawals at birth, known as neonatal abstinence syndrome.
Blake Farmer

But it's a nuanced problem with no consensus on where money is most needed, even among those who have been working on the problem for years.

Justin Lanning started Nashville-based 180 Health Partners, which works with mothers at risk of delivering a baby dependent on opioids. Most are covered by Medicaid. And those Medicaid departments in each state pay for most of the NAS births in the U.S.

"We have a few departments in our country that can operate at an epidemic scale, and I think that's where we have to focus our funds," he says.

Lanning sees a need to extend government-funded insurance for new mothers, since in states like Tennessee that never expanded Medicaid, these moms can lose health coverage just two months after giving birth. That often derails the mother's own drug treatment funded by Medicaid, he says.

"This consistency of care is so key to their recovery, to their productivity, to their thriving," Lanning says of new mothers in recovery.

Nicholson now has a job at 180 Health Partners, assisting and mentoring pregnant women struggling with addiction. Nicholson says their biggest need is a stable place to live and reliable transportation.

"I just feel kind of hopeless," she says. "I don't know what to tell these women."

There are many needs, Nicholson says, but no simple fix. Those who work with mothers in recovery fear any opioid settlement money may be spread so thin that it doesn't benefit their children — the next generation of the crisis.


This story comes from NPR's reporting partnership with Nashville Public Radio and Kaiser Health News.

Copyright 2019 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

AILSA CHANG, HOST:

The addiction crisis has seeped into nearly every aspect of U.S. life. Among the most vulnerable victims are tens of thousands of babies born every year to mothers who took opioids. The image of these trembling, crying babies in hospital nurseries is often invoked by lawyers suing the opioid companies. But as WPLN's Blake Farmer reports, some worry that when those lawsuits end, there won't be any money left for those babies as they grow.

BLAKE FARMER, BYLINE: Neonatal abstinence syndrome - or NAS, as it's known - was only recently something doctors even looked for. The numbers quadrupled over a decade. The condition can result in tremors, seizures and even breathing trouble in the first days of life. Robbie Nicholson of Eagleville, Tenn., knows what it's like to watch your baby withdrawing from drugs you were taking.

ROBBIE NICHOLSON: The whole experience was just traumatizing, really.

FARMER: Nicholson's ordeal goes back to her first pregnancy. Afterwards, she was prescribed a pile of Percocets by her doctor. That was the norm.

NICHOLSON: Back then, it was like I was on them for, like, a full month. And then he was like, OK, you're done. And I was like, oh, my God. I've got a newborn - first-time mom, no energy, no sleep. Like, that was getting me through. And so it just built - build and build and build off that.

FARMER: After developing a full-blown addiction to painkillers, she eventually found her way into recovery, taking medication to keep her opioid cravings at bay. And then another pregnancy. The trouble is medication-assisted drug treatment, which involves taking a special kind of opioid, can still result in withdrawals for the newborn. Hospitals have gotten pretty good at weaning them, but not much is known about the long-term effects.

NICHOLSON: And I wanted her to be perfect. And she is absolutely perfect. But just that in the back of my mind is always going to be there.

(SOUNDBITE OF TODDLER BABBLING)

NICHOLSON: That's daddy.

(SOUNDBITE OF TODDLER BABBLING)

FARMER: That's Nicholson's youngest, now a toddler. She's happy and healthy, if a bit strong-willed, Nicholson says. There are thousands of children like her entering the education system. And neonatologist Stephen Patrick says this is where money is so desperately needed.

STEPHEN PATRICK: So you hear teachers talking about infants with a developmental delay. I mean, I just got an email this morning from somebody.

FARMER: Patrick says no one's shown a direct link between NAS and behavior problems in kids, but that's where more research is headed. As states, cities counties and even hospitals are going after drug companies in court, Patrick fears the kids will be left out. He leads the Center for Child Health Policy at Vanderbilt University.

PATRICK: It's somewhere where we need to be in the mix right now in schools, understanding how we can support teachers, how we can support students as they try to learn, even as we work out, was there cause and effect of opioid use and developmental delays or issues in school?

FARMER: But it's a nuanced problem with no consensus on where money's most needed, even among those who've been working on the problem for years. Justin Lanning started 180 Health Partners, which works with mothers at risk of delivering a drug-dependent baby. He sees a need to fund government insurance for new mothers since, in some states, coverage goes away after just two months. He says that often derails the mother's own drug treatment funded by Medicaid.

JUSTIN LANNING: This consistency of care is so key to their recovery, to their productivity, to their thriving.

FARMER: Lanning's company hires mothers who've been there to act as mentors. Robbie Nicholson is one of them. In working directly with these pregnant women struggling with addiction, she says their biggest need is a stable place to live and reliable transportation.

NICHOLSON: It's just I feel kind of hopeless because I'm like, oh, my God, I don't know what to tell these women.

FARMER: There are many needs, Nicholson says, but no simple fix. Those who work with mothers in recovery fear any opioid settlement money may be spread so thin that it doesn't benefit their children, the next generation of the crisis.

For NPR News, I'm Blake Farmer in Nashville. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.